In The Name of Allah, The Most Merciful, The Bestower of Mercy.

I ask Allah during these challenging times of Fitan, asking Him to safeguard me, my wife, my children, and grandchildren from all trials, and to protect all Muslims and their offspring, Amin. Two of my beloved sons – from my own household – always seek the verdicts of scholars on various matters. After one of them posed a question to me today, I am sharing with him this example from a response given by Imam Abdul Aziz Bin Baz, may Allah have mercy on him, concerning the pursuit of truth. Life is short, and as we approach our mid-50s, we cannot help but reflect on what the Messenger, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, stated about the average lifespan of this Ummah. Thus, we ask Allah to grant us life as long as it is good for us and to take us when death is good for us. I pass on this advice to my beloved son, and may Allah bless him and all Muslim children, Amin.

السؤال: هذا السائل أحمد كشوقة من الأردن عمان يقول: سماحة الشيخ: إذا اختلفت أقوال العلماء في حكم مسألة ما، فمنهم من قال: مكروه، ومنهم من قال: حرام، ومنهم من قال: لا يجوز، فهل أحسن القول في هذه الأحكام هو الحرام؟ وهل هذا دائمًا؟ وإذا اختلفوا على مسألة بأنها جائزة مستحبة لا بأس بها فهل الأحسن القول هو الاستحباب؟ وهل هذا دائمًا، وجهونا بهذا مأجورين؟
الجواب: هذا فيه تفصيل على المستفتي أن ينظر في الأمر، ويتحرى من هو أقرب إلى الخير والعلم والفضل وأقرب إلى إصابة الحق حتى يأخذ بفتواه، وإذا احتاط والمسألة: هذا يقول: حرام، وهذا يقول: ليس بحرام، واحتاط وترك ذلك فهذا حسن؛ لقول النبي ﷺ: دع ما يريبك إلى ما لا يريبك من اتقى الشبهات فقد استبرأ لدينه وعرضه ولكن إذا تيسر له أن يتحرى حتى يعرف من هو أكثر علمًا، ومن هو أكثر ورعًا، ومن هو أقرب إلى الصواب حتى يأخذ بقوله، حتى يطمئن قلبه، مثلما قال ﷺ: استفت قلبك البر ما اطمأنت إليه النفس واطمأن إليه القلب، إذا اختلفت عليه الفتاوى، إذا اختلفت الفتوى فالمؤمن ينظر ويتأمل ولا يعجل، يتحرى من هو أقرب إلى الناس للإصابة من أهل العلم والبصيرة والورع والذي يرجح في قلبه أنه أقرب إلى الخير وأقرب إلى إصابة الحق، وهكذا في الاستحباب إذا اختلفوا هذا سنة أو مباح يتحرى، فإذا غلب على قلبه واطمأن قلبه إلى قول من قال: إنه مستحب، عمل عمل المستحب، وإذا اطمأن قلبك إلى أنه مباح فقط عامله معاملة المباح.
والمقصود من هذا كله أن المستفتي أو السامع ينظر ويتأمل ولا يعجل، وينظر حال المفتين وأحوالهم، وينظر ما هو أقرب إلى الخير من جهة ورعهم ومن جهة تحريهم الحق، ومن جهة سمعتهم الحسنة، إلى غير ذلك

https://binbaz.org.sa/fatwas/8821/%D9%85%D9%88%D9%82%D9%81-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D8%B3%D8%AA%D9%81%D8%AA%D9%8A-%D8%A7%D8%B0%D8%A7-%D8%A7%D8%AE%D8%AA%D9%84%D9%81%D8%AA-%D8%A7%D9%82%D9%88%D8%A7%D9%84-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D9%81%D8%AA%D9%8A%D9%86

The question: This questioner, Ahmad Kashuqah from Amman, Jordan, says: O revered Shaikh, when the statements of the scholars differ regarding the ruling on a particular issue—some saying it is Makruh (disliked), some say it is Haraam (unlawful) and some say Laa Yajuz (it is not allowed), is the verdict Haraam the best of these statements and is this always the case? And if they differ regarding a matter being allowed, recommended and that there is no harm regarding it, is the verdict recommended the best statement, and is this always the case?

Response: There is a detail clarification regarding this matter. It is incumbent upon the one seeking a verdict to examine the matter, [ويتحرى من هو أقرب إلى الخير والعلم والفضل وأقرب إلى إصابة الحق – and he (carefully) seeks out the one who is closer to goodness, knowledge, and virtue, and closer to attaining the truth] in order to follow their fatwa. If one exercises caution, while the matter is a situation where this one says “haraam”, that one says “It is not Haraam”, he exercises caution and leaves it. This would be better. The Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, said: “Leave that which makes you doubt for that which does not make you doubt.” [a] “So whoever took caution regarding the ambiguous matters has absolved himself regarding his religion and his honour”.[b]

However, if he is able, he carefully seeks until he knows [من هو أكثر علمًا، ومن هو أكثر ورعًا، ومن هو أقرب إلى الصواب – who has more knowledge, has more of that fear of Allah that makes a person abandon doubtful matters out of fear of falling into Haram, and the one who is closer to reaching what is correct] in order to follow his statement and so that his heart is at ease, similar to what the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, said: “Consult your heart”. [c] Righteousness is that about which the soul feels tranquil and the heart feels tranquil. If faced with differing fatwas, if the Fatwa differs, a believer examines and contemplates, and he is not hasty; [يتحرى من هو أقرب إلى الناس للإصابة من أهل العلم والبصيرة والورع والذي يرجح في قلبه أنه أقرب إلى الخير وأقرب إلى إصابة الحق – he seeks among the people of knowledge the one closest to reaching the truth, the possessors of clear-sightedness and that fear of Allah that makes a person avoid doubtful matters out of fear of falling into what is forbidden – the one his heart considers to be closer to good and closer to reaching the truth].

Similarly, in matters of recommendation, if there is disagreement regarding whether something is recommended or permissible, one should carefully consider the opinions. If his heart holds an overwhelming inclination -based on what is apparent – towards the statement of the one who says that the matter is recommended, he should act on the recommendation. If your heart is at ease that the matter is permissible only, it should be treated as permissible. The goal (intent) regarding all of this is that the one who seeks fatwa or the listener should examine and contemplate without haste, he examines the situation and circumstances of the Muftis, and he examines what is closer to good in terms of them having that fear of Allah that makes a person avoid doubtful matters out of fear of falling into Haram, their careful pursuit of the truth, and their good reputation, among other things. [end of quote] [Paraphrased]

In saying all this, Taqleed has its precise place. Al-Allamah Salih Al-Fawzan, may Allah have mercy upon him, stated on this link that the layperson or the beginner in the path of knowledge has no option but to make Taqleed because they do not have the ability to make Ijtihaad, so they make Taqleed of the people of knowledge, as Allah said:

فَسْـَٔلُوٓا۟ أَهْلَ ٱلذِّكْرِ إِن كُنتُمْ لَا تَعْلَمُونَ

Ask Ahl Adh-Dhikr (the people of Shariah knowledge) if you do not know. [d] [end of quote]

I am reminding my beloved son who constantly seeks clarification regarding what the scholars say in different subject matters that Al-Allamah Salih Al-Fawzan, Al-Allamah Abdul Muhsin, and Al-Allamah Salih Aala Ash-Shaikh are still alive, may Allah preserve them. The students of Al-Allamah Rabee, Al-Allamah Ubaid, Al-Allamah Muqbil Bin Haadi, and others, may Allah have mercy upon them, continue to clarify issues at various levels of knowledge. However, give precedence to the senior scholars first – Al-Allamah Salih Al-Fawzan, Al-Allamah Abdul Muhsin, and Al-Allamah Salih Aala Ash-Shaikh. Additionally, benefit from all the other well-known students of these scholars, who include both scholars and senior students of knowledge. However, for great matters, we must consult Al-Allamah Salih Al-Fawzan and Al-Allamah Abdul Muhsin. Respect and love all the upright people of knowledge in the Muslim lands, the likes of Shaikh Mustapha Mubram, Shaikh Abdullah Al-Bukhari, Shaikh Khalid Adh-Dhufayri, Shaikh Nizaar, Shaikh Ahmad Az-Zahrani, and others, and also respect your Mashayikh in other parts of the world. Always ask Allah to enable you to follow the truth.  There is no harm in Taqleed with sincerity and honesty, as I have referenced the statement of Al-Allamah Salih Al-Fawzan regarding this.

Furthermore, the scholars were well-known to us in the West in 1995 after Allah guided us to the Sunnah. We loved, respected, and defended them. Many issues were clarified for us through them via their upright students. We benefitted and continue to benefit from all upright scholars and students of knowledge regardless of their varying levels of knowledge and age, but big matters were always reserved for the senior scholars. Similarly, in the present day, benefit from all truthful scholars. Finally, after identifying the senior scholars like Al-Allamah Salih Al-Fawzan, Al-Allamah Abdul Muhsin, and Al-Allamah Salih Aala Ash-Shaikh, refrain from engaging in debates about others because neither have they asked you to debate their matter nor is it befitting that you engage yourself in that which is not beneficial. Instead, focus on learning from all upright possessors of knowledge in our era, and your aim should always be searching for the truth and follow evidence to the best of your ability. Do not concern yourself with those who utter lies, persist upon lies and deception, and be distant from those drowned in exaggeration and propaganda in the East and the West. And give no consideration to Ahlul Bidah. May Allah bless you. I ask you to pardon me for all the shortcomings that have manifested from me while doing my best to nurture you. May Allah bless you and your family, and all my other children, and all the children of the Muslims Amin.

Footnotes:
[a] https://www.nawawis40hadith.com/nw/hadith/11/leaving-doubt
[b] https://www.nawawis40hadith.com/nw/hadith/6/the-doubtful-matters
[c] https://www.nawawis40hadith.com/nw/hadith/27/righteousness-and-sin
[d] https://www.alfawzan.af.org.sa/ar/node/15726