Skip to main content

Set a trap in the Mas’alah 


بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم

Set a trap in the Mas’alah that draws him into using stratagems, relying on guesses, or venturing into Khilafaat he does not understand. 

 

NO STRATAGEMS

Imam Al-Barbahaaree, may Allah have mercy upon him, said: Al-Hasan (al-Basree) said, “The wise man does not argue or seek to overcome with stratagem rather he propagates his wisdom. If it is accepted, he praises Allah and if it is rejected he praises Allah”. [Sharh As-Sunnah]

Al-Allamah Salih Al-Fawzan, may Allah have mercy upon him, said:

The wise man is the one who possesses wisdom, and wisdom is to place something in its place. Similarly, the wise one means the one with understanding. He does not debate (with) a fruitless debate that is devoid of benefit. He propagates his knowledge and if accepted he praises Allah. This is what is sought after.  If it is not accepted, he is absolved of his responsibility and the proof is conveyed. “He praises Allah” because he established and conveyed the proof, and fulfilled what is required of him, and the guiding of the hearts is in the hands of Allah. [1]

NO GUESSING

Allah, The Most High, said:

سَيَقُولُونَ ثَلَاثَةٌ رَّابِعُهُمْ كَلْبُهُمْ وَيَقُولُونَ خَمْسَةٌ سَادِسُهُمْ كَلْبُهُمْ رَجْمًا بِالْغَيْبِ ۖ وَيَقُولُونَ سَبْعَةٌ وَثَامِنُهُمْ كَلْبُهُمْ ۚ قُل رَّبِّي أَعْلَمُ بِعِدَّتِهِم مَّا يَعْلَمُهُمْ إِلَّا قَلِيلٌ ۗ فَلَا تُمَارِ فِيهِمْ إِلَّا مِرَاءً ظَاهِرًا وَلَا تَسْتَفْتِ فِيهِم مِّنْهُمْ أَحَدًا

[Some] say they were three, the dog being the fourth among them; (others) say they were five, the dog being the sixth, guessing at the unseen; (yet others) say they were seven, the dog being the eighth. Say (O Muhammad): “My Lord knows best their number; none knows them but a few.” So debate not (about their number, etc.) except with the clear proof (which We have revealed to you). And consult not any of them (people of the Scripture) about (the affair of) the people of the Cave. [Al-Kahf 22]

Allah informed us of the differing between the people of the scripture regarding the number of the people of the cave- a differing out of guessing at the unseen, forging statements and speaking about that which they have no knowledge. Some of them said that the people of the cave were three in number and their dog was the fourth, and others said that the people of the cave were five in number and their dog was the sixth. Allah said that these two statements are tantamount to guessing at the unseen, thus this indicates that they are false. Amongst them were those who said that the people of the cave were seven in number and their dog was the eighth. This statement- and Allah knows best- is what is correct because Allah declared the first two statements false but did not declare this third one to be false, indicating that it is correct.

This differing is one that neither carries any benefit nor are the people benefited by knowing the number of the people of the cave. It contains neither a benefit related to religion nor the worldly affairs and that is why Allah stated:

قُل رَّبِّي أَعْلَمُ بِعِدَّتِهِم مَّا يَعْلَمُهُمْ إِلَّا قَلِيلٌ ۗ

Say (O Muhammad):My Lord knows best their number; none knows them but a few]; and they are those who know what is correct and known for being upon what is correct.

فَلَا تُمَارِ فِيهِمْ إِلَّا مِرَاءً ظَاهِرً

So debate not (about their number, etc.) except with the clear proof (which We have revealed to you)] – Meaning, based upon knowledge, certainty and about that which contains benefit. As for debating based on ignorance and guessing at the unseen or about that which has no benefit- either the debater being obstinate or the affair being debated having no benefit- neither any religious nor worldly benefit, such as the number of the people of the cave and what is similar to it, too much debate and continuous research regarding it is a waste of time, and it makes the hearts have a strong love for that which has no benefit.

 وَلَا تَسْتَفْتِ فِيهِم مِّنْهُمْ أَحَدً

And consult not any of them (people of the Scripture, Jews and Christians) about (the affair of) the people of the Cave] – Meaning, because their speech regarding it is based on guessing at the unseen, and conjecture can be of no avail against the truth.

This proves that it is not permissible for a person to issue a verdict when he is not worthy of it- either due to his inability to issue a verdict in that affair or due to fact that he does not care what he says about the affair because he does not possess that fear of Allah that would stop him from speaking about affairs that are unclear to him, which may harm him in the afterlife. Therefore, when it is the case that he has been forbidden from giving verdicts in the likes of this affair, then prohibiting him from giving verdicts is of a greater prohibition. Also this Ayah proves that a person maybe prohibited from giving a verdict in some matters but not in other matters so he gives a verdict in that which he is worthy of giving a verdict and not in other affairs because Allah has not prohibited him from giving a verdict completely; rather they were prohibited from giving a verdict regarding the affair of the people of the cave and what is similar to it. [2]

NO UNNECESSARY SPEECH IN THE KHILAAFAAT

When reporting a difference of opinion on a matter, one should accommodate the statements (or arguments or views) in that context- clarify what is sound and what is false, mention the beneficial points in that difference of opinion and its fruitful outcomes so that the disagreement and differing is not prolonged in that which has no benefit, thus preoccupying one with other than what is more important. As for the one who transmits difference of opinion, but does not accommodate the statements of the scholars, he has fallen short because it may be that what is correct is found in that which he left out, or he transmits difference of opinion but neither establish its proofs nor clarifies the correct statements, he has also fallen short. If he deliberately portrays something wrong as something correct, he has lied deliberately, and he is mistaken if it was based on ignorance. Also, the one who transmits difference of opinion in that which there is no benefit or merely transmits the wording of a number of statements (views) and then summarises them in one or two statements in meaning, then indeed he has wasted a long time and prolonged engagement in that which is not correct”. [3] [end of quotes]

May Allāh guide us and you. This website is simply a place to share Fawaa’id from scholars and upright students of knowledge with our community. If anything shared here burdens you, that is not our intention. So, when someone tries to draw us into a subtle Mas’alah and use us to spread their propaganda, we know that they are trying to make others accuse us of being careless in distinguishing truth from responsible disclosure. They wish that as soon as we are trapped in this manner, we’ll be forced to rely on stratagems, guesses, or to enter into Khilafaat whose depths we do not know. There is no need for these games.

In this era, issues will arise that scholars, both past and present, have already explained—the Salaf addressed them first and foremost. Familiar matters will come up again, and many people know their foundations. Scholars may explain them differently, not because they contradict one another, but to clarify the issues and explain limits and allowances in different circumstances. For example, in the 90s, the Shubuhat of the Qutubiyyun and Suririyyun were rife, especially around Takfir, enjoining good and forbidding evil. The scholars did not shy away from explaining its intricacies when the need arose. These matters were not dealt with in one or two articles through the translations of Shaikh Abu Talhah, may Allāh have mercy upon him, and Shaikh Abu Iyaad, may Allāh preserve him, rather, they required many translations from the clarifications of the senior scholars from different angles. And there were further clarifications whenever ahlul bidah and others repackaged their doubts and ambiguities on Takfir, rebellion, relationship with the rulers, irjaa, enjoining good and forbidding evil, politics and political activism. We could not understand all these matters at once, rather, it took some time to grasp some of their more intricate and ambiguous aspects. However, during private gatherings with reliable teachers, they took time to explain things clearly. They made sure we would not leave with unanswered questions, repeating their explanations transmitted from the senior scholars and giving different examples until we understood.

They used to explain to us that there is a difference between explaining the circumstances in which a ruling applies and explaining who has the knowledge and authority to decide whether a specific case falls within an exception. These points do not always need to be presented to every audience at once or in every religious discussion. 

Detailed clarifications were always available to explain the difference between explaining the prohibition of something to the general public in a manner that fulfils the objectives as opposed to a robust discussion between students when  necessary to clarify the conditions, exceptions, and relevant circumstances surrounding an intricate issue. Thus, we gradually understood that addressing the issue in general because the audience is not suited to a detailed explanation does not mean denying that those details exist. 

Furthermore, we witnessed in person when reliable carriers of knowledge would mention a well known general ruling from a scholar, while another reliable carrier of knowledge explained specific circumstances and exceptions from another scholar. We did not see the first accuse the second of confusing ordinary people by adding details he had chosen not to mention. Instead, the discussion focused on the actual statements, evidence, context, and scholarly principles—not on assumptions. Present the evidence and explain what it proves. Therefore, when you encounter similar matters today, refer them to scholars for clarifications, rather than harboring unfounded evil suspicions. The objective is not to lay traps or to win an argument, rather, the objective is to convey the religious ruling honestly from the scholars, accurately, place every matter in its proper context and protect the audience from misunderstanding. In this regard, we have this remarkable incident narrated by Imam Ibn Hazm, may Allah have mercy upon him. He said: 

I had a debate with one of our companions regarding a Mas’alah and I gained the upper hand. The gathering ended with the (view) that indeed I was right. Then when I returned to my house, something about the issue continued to trouble me. So, I searched for it in some books and found a sound proof that clarified the falsity of my position and the correctness of my opponent’s position. There was one of our companions who was with me in that gathering, so I informed him of what I had found. Then I marked the relevant place in the book. He said to me: ‘What do you want to do?’ I said to him: ‘Take this book, give it to so-and-so, inform him that he was correct and that I was mistaken, and tell him that I am returning to his view.’ He was amazed by this and said: ‘And can you bring yourself to do such a thing?!’ I replied: ‘Yes! If I were able to do so right now, I would not delay it until tomorrow.’” [4]

Furthermore, we learnt that there is a difference between not mentioning an exception because it is irrelevant to the immediate lesson and not mentioning it when the question being examined cannot be answered correctly without it.

Finally, there is another issue connected to generosity in sharing knowledge. In Madarij As-Salikin under the heading:

فصل : مراتب الجود

Imam Ibn Al-Qayyim, may Allah have mercy upon him, discussed generosity and its various levels, emphasising that to be generous with one’s knowledge is among the highest forms of generosity.

Being generous with knowledge is considered more virtuous than being generous with wealth, as knowledge is deemed more noble than wealth. Generosity with knowledge entails providing a detailed and comprehensive answer when someone inquires about religious matters, rather than just giving a sufficient response to meet their immediate needs.

He then proceeded to discuss his observations on Shaikh Al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah concerning this matter, noting that when asked about a matter necessitating a ruling, he would, when possible, refer to the teachings of the four Imams, explain the reasons for their varying opinions, and highlight what carried more weight.

Additionally, he would bring up other matters about the topic that could potentially provide even greater advantages for the individual posing the question than the specific issue they inquired about.

Imam Ibn Al-Qayyim then mentioned an example in the Sunnah concerning this issue that the companions once inquired from the prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, about performing ablution with seawater. In response, he stated: “Its water is purifying and its dead (animals) are lawful (to eat)”. 

Thus, the Prophet not only addressed their initial query but also generously provided them with something that they would be more in need of at certain times. [5] [end of quote]

So, either you understand this well or go ahead laying traps to lure people into matters which you will use to accuse others of bringing them up to confuse the masses. 


[1] An Excerpt from It’haf Al-Qari Bitta’liqaat Alaa Sharh As- Sunnah Lil Imam Barbahaaree. 2/265-266

[2] An Excerpt from Tayseer Al-Kareem Ar-Rahmaan Fee Tafseer Kalaam al-Mannaan.

[3] Manhaj Al-Bahth Al-Ilmi Wa Kitaabah Fee Uloom Ash-Shariah 21- 22

[4] at-Taqrīb li-Ḥadd al-Manṭiq. p. 194

[5] Madarij As-Salikin 2/43-44 

Share


Related Posts

FOLLOW US


Donate to the Dawah in Manchester

Join the Umrah Trip