Skip to main content

Is The Statement Of A Companion Proof In And of Itself?


بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم

Imam Abdul Aziz Bin Baz, may Allah have mercy upon him, was asked: With regards to the statement of a Companion (or a position held by a Companion): Is his statement considered evidence if it does not oppose a divine textual evidence?

Response: In the view of many of the people of knowledge, it is indeed evidence if it is neither opposed by another person nor contradicted by a text from the Book of Allah or the Sunnah, and if it is not opposed by any of the other Companions. Thus, it is a strong position that such a statement is used as evidence, because indeed, they (the Companions) were the most knowledgeable of people after the Prophets. [1] [paraphrased]

Imam Al-Albani, may Allah have mercy upon him, was asked: (The question): It is with regards—in particular—to when the statement of a Companion is considered evidence and when it is not considered evidence.

Response: The Shaikh: Firstly, if he has not opposed a Shariah text by way of his opinion, then the question arises as follows: if it contradicts a text from the Qur’an or the Sunnah, then the statement of the Companion is not used as evidence. As for if his statement does not oppose (either of them), then if the person who wishes to oppose that statement is a Mujtahid among the Imams of Islam, he must find, within his preserved knowledge, evidence from the Book and the Sunnah that make him see the opposing position against the statement of that Companion; otherwise, following the Companion is what is incumbent upon him, because indeed, there is no doubt that the Companions were more knowledgeable than us, more fearful of Allah, possessed more understanding of the religion, and so on.

In order to understand the answer correctly and easily: if a statement that is reported from a Companion does not oppose the Book or the Sunnah, and it reaches one of the Imams among the Imams of Ijtihad, and he finds within his preserved (memorised) knowledge evidence from the Book and the Sunnah from which he can derive an understanding that leads him to a position contrary to the statement of that Companion, then that is permissible for him. And if he does not find (the proof), then it is incumbent upon him to follow that Companion. This is the answer. [2] [paraphrased]

Al-Allamah Rabee Bin Hadi Al-Mad’khali, may Allah have mercy upon him, was asked: Are the statements of the Imams and Scholars of the Salaf, may Allah, the Most High, have mercy upon them, during the first three generations, an evidence to which one refers back?

Response: Indeed, the statements of the Imams of the Salaf during the virtuous generations, if they are from the angle of established consensus, then they are an evidence. So, whatever they unanimously agreed upon with regards to matters of creed, acts of worship and dealings [it is an evidence]. From the foundational principles of Ahlus-Sunnah are the Book, the Sunnah and Ijmaa.

And if they (i.e. the issues) are not among the matters upon which there is consensus, then it is incumbent upon the people of knowledge to refer back to the Book of Allah and the Sunnah of His Messenger, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, and what can be used as evidence from them regarding the correctness (or the nullity of the statement), as Allah, the Most High, said:

فإن تنازعتم في شيء فردوه إلى الله والرسول إن كنتم تؤمنون بالله واليوم الآخر ذلك خير وأحسن تأويلا

And if you disagree among yourselves over anything, then refer it back to Allah and the Messenger, if you truly believe in Allah and the Last Day. That is better (conduct) and (leads to) the most excellent outcome. [4:59]

And His, The Most High, statement:

وما اختلفتم فيه من شيء فحكمه إلى الله

And in whatsoever you differ, the decision thereof is with Allah (He is the ruling Judge). [42:10]

This is our position regarding the statements of the Imams of the virtuous generations, may Allah, the Most High, have mercy upon them. [3] [paraphrased]

Here is also a statement of Imam Muhammad Ibn Salih Al-Uthaymin, may Allah have mercy upon him

السائل : بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم .
فضيلة الشيخ : نرجو توضيح هذه المسألة أن بعض الناس قد يستدل للحكم على مسألة معينة بقول صحابي أو فعله.
الشيخ : قد يستدل بالدليل على حكمه.
السائل : بالدليل نعم ويكون يستدل بقول صحابي أو فعله أو فتواه ويكون يعني من السنّة دليل أشمل وأقوى وأوضح من فعل الصحابي، وإذا قلت له شيء قال إن ذلك باتباع سنة الخلفاء الراشدين، يعني هل يعتبر فعل الصحابي وحده منفرد سنة من سنة الخلفاء أم لا؟
الشيخ : أولاً بارك الله فيك العلماء مختلفون هل قول الصحابي حجة أو لا؟ فمن العلماء من قال: لا حجة إلا في ما قال الله ورسوله ولهذا قال تعالى: (( وَمَا اخْتَلَفْتُمْ فِيهِ مِنْ شَيْءٍ فَحُكْمُهُ إِلَى اللَّه )) وقال: (( فَإِنْ تَنَازَعْتُمْ فِي شَيْءٍ فَرُدُّوهُ إِلَى اللَّهِ وَالرَّسُولِ )) لم يذكر طرفاً ثالثاً، فقول الصحابي كقول غيره ليس بحجة، لكن لا شك أن الصحابة أقرب إلى الصواب ممن بعدهم.
ومنهم من قال: إن قول الصحابي حجة إذا كان من أهل العلم والفقه، لأنك كما تعرف إذا جاء أعرابي عند النبي عليه الصلاة والسلام وأسلم ثم رجع إلى إبله فهو صحابي، قد يكون جاهلاً في كثير من مسائل العلم، لكن إذا كان الصحابي من الفقهاء المعروفين بالفقه فإن قوله حجة بشرطين: الشرط الأول: ألا يخالف قول الله ورسوله، والشرط الثاني أن لا يخالف قول صحابي آخر، فإن خالف قول الله ورسوله وجب طرحه والأخذ بما قال الله ورسوله.
قال ابن عباس رضي الله عنهما: “يوشك أن تنزل عليكم حجارة من السماء، أقول: قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم وتقولون: قال أبو بكر وعمر ” وقال الله تعالى: (( فَلْيَحْذَرِ الَّذِينَ يُخَالِفُونَ عَنْ أَمْرِهِ )) أي: عن أمر الرسول عليه الصلاة والسلام (( أَنْ تُصِيبَهُمْ فِتْنَةٌ أَوْ يُصِيبَهُمْ عَذَابٌ أَلِيمٌ )) قال الإمام أحمد: ” أتدري ما الفتنة؟ الفتنة الشرك، لعله إذا رد بعض قول الرسول أن يقع في قلبه شيء من الزيغ فيهلك “، نسأل الله العافية.
الشرط الثاني: ألا يخالف قول صحابي آخر، فإن خالف قول صحابي آخر وجب النظر في الراجح، لأنه ليس أحدهما أولى بالقبول من الآخر، لكن ننظر في الراجح، فإذا كان أحد المخالفين أدنى من الآخر في الفقه في دين الله قدم الأعلم.
وأما إذا عارض قول الله ورسوله فإنه مطرح وهو مقتضى قول الرسول عليه الصلاة والسلام : ( عليكم بسنتي وسنة الخلفاء الراشدين ) فقدم أولاً سنته، سنته مقدمة على كل شيء.

End of Quotes

Over thirty years ago, all we heard was: “Where is the Dalil?” In our Manchester study circles, proofs were always presented from the Ayat, Ahadith and understanding of the Sahabah. Senior scholars were cited to aid understanding, never merely as authorities without mentioning the Dalil, even when we could not fully understand their reasoning. One incident that lifted our spirits was during a Bulugh Al-Maram study circle, when the teacher referred to Silsilah As-Saheehah regarding Abu Bakrah, may Allah be pleased with him, making Ruku before reaching the rows. He explained the Prophet’s instruction not to repeat this action, why it was permissible and why the prayer did not need repeating, citing statements of the Salaf. It was during lessons like these that we constantly heard this principle about using the Sahabah as proof and, sometimes, why their position is not used as proof. These discussions touched every topic.

During some Fitan of the Mubtadi’ah, we were safeguarded by the Tawfiq of Allah, and personalities were never considered when they opposed the proofs. So, during the Fitan of Abul Hasan Al-Maribi and Al-Hajuri, we witnessed how clinging to personalities damaged the sound reasoning of some. As for at present, social media has worsened this calamity, providing a platform for propaganda, evasion, emotional appeals and whataboutism. People can now evade discussion that should be based on Dalil, attract new audiences and use their fame, reputation or beautiful quotes to lure people to their side. Some change their stances yet expect acceptance because of who they are and the crowd defending them. They would convey a statement from so and so personality, then ask whether you are more knowledgeable, while preventing the question: “Where is the proof?” Social media credentials replace evidence, and requests for proof are treated as suspicion. Tolerance is demanded for the mistakes of their beloved, influential one, while those with less influence are pressured, isolated and harmed for questioning them.

Therefore, we say to the opinionated ones: If a Companion’s statement is examined before being used as proof, why accept statements from people today without asking for Dalil? When we follow Dalil or ask for it, we are accused of disrespecting people of knowledge. PDFs praise them, while issues are sidelined, their serious mistakes trivialised and lesser slips of others are inflated. We must remain silent or face shouting, intellectual terrorism, private warnings and gatekeeping. Are they above the Sahabah? By Allah, we will not submit or fear isolation. Death will come amid unfinished ambitions, therefore, one must hold to the Book and Sunnah as understood and implemented by the Companions.

Alhamdulil laah, the senior scholars are alive, such as Al-Allamah Salih Al-Fawzan, Al-Allamah Abdul Muhsin Al-Abbad and Al-Allamah Salih Aala Ash-Shaikh, and numerous students of the upright scholars are alive as well. There are many people who still hold on to the principles and do not sell them for a cheap price, nor do they say one thing and do another thing. May Allāh grant us Ikhlas, Sidq, Thabat and Husnukl Khatimah. 


[1]

https://binbaz.org.sa/fatwas/22818/%D9%85%D8%A7-%D8%B4%D8%B1%D9%88%D8%B7-%D8%AD%D8%AC%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D9%82%D9%88%D9%84-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B5%D8%AD%D8%A7%D8%A8%D9%8A

[2]

بخصوص يعني الصحابي متى يعتبر قوله حجة ومتى لا يعتبر قوله حجة ؟

الشيخ : أوَّلًا إذا كان لم يعارض برأيه نصاً شرعياً فهنا يرد هذا السؤال أن إذا كان معارضاً لنص في القرآن أو في السنة فحينئذٍ لا يحتج بقول الصحابي أما إذا كان قوله لا يخالف فحينئذٍ إن كان الذي يريد أن يخالف هذا القول مجتهداً من أئمة المسلمين فلا بد أن يجد في محفوظاته من أدلة الكتاب والسنة ما يصور له المخالف قول ذلك الصحابي وإلا فاتباعه للصحابي هو الواجب عليه لأنه بلا شك أن الصحابة كانوا أعلم منا وأتقى وأفقه ونحو ذلك …. لكي يفهم الجواب بصحة وبسهولة إذا كان القول المروي عن الصحابي لا يخالف كتاباً ولا سنة وورد إلى إمام من أئمة المجتهدين ووجد في محفوظاته من الكتاب والسنة ما يمكن أن يتفقه فيهما ويأخذ منهما خلاف قول هذا الصحابي فذلك جائز له وإن لم يجد وجب عليه أن يتبع هذا الصحابي ، هذا هو الجواب ، تفضل

[3]  https://rabee.net/alfatawi/%D9%87%D9%84-%D9%82%D9%88%D9%84-%D8%A3%D8%A6%D9%85%D8%A9-%D9%88%D8%B9%D9%84%D9%85%D8%A7%D8%A1-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B3%D9%84%D9%81-%D8%B1%D8%AD%D9%85%D9%87%D9%85-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%84%D9%87-%D8%AA%D8%B9/

هل قول أئمة وعلماء السلف -رحمهم الله تعالى- في القرون الثلاثة حجة يرجع إليها
إن أقوال أئمة السلف في القرون المفضلة إن كانت من باب الإجماعات، قامت، فهي حجة، فما أجمعوا عليه في العقائد والعبادات والمعاملات [فهو حجة]، من أصول أهل السنة، الكتاب والسنة والإجماع.
وإن لم تكن من الأمور المجمع عليها فالواجب على أهل العلم أن يرجعوا إلى كتاب الله وسنة رسوله صلى الله عليه وسلم، وما [يستدل به] منهما على صحة [أو بطلان القول]، كما قال تعالى (فإن تنازعتم في شيء فردوه إلى الله والرسول إن كنتم تؤمنون بالله واليوم الآخر ذلك خير وأحسن تأويلا) وقوله تعالى (وما اختلفتم فيه من شيء فحكمه إلى الله) هذا موقفنا من أقوال الأئمة في القرون المفضلة رحمهم الله تعالى.

FOLLOW US


Donate to the Dawah in Manchester

Join the Umrah Trip